make -C v4 post79: docs/v4.0.0/POST.md differs run to run (addresses and inference values in v3's column) #199

Open
opened 2026-11-20 14:52:26 +00:00 by rajames · 0 comments
Owner

Found (2026-11-20, while checking #190)

make -C v4 post79 writes docs/v4.0.0/POST.md, the 990-case table, as well as post_cases.c and POST79.md. Those two are now the same run to run (#190), but POST.md is not. Two runs on the same tree differ in five cells of its "v3 printed" column (logs/20261120-post79/run1-vs-run2.diff):

  • three are addresses: FIND.user_word, >BODY.basic and >BODY.variable, despite setarch -R;
  • two come of the run's own history: INFER-VARIANCE@.after_run and INFER-EARLY-EXIT@.after_run.

The cases POST runs are not affected, since v4's side does not compare these values. But POST.md, which says the tool writes it, cannot be checked against the tool, and every run leaves it modified.

Done when

  • Two runs of make -C v4 post79 on the same tree write the same POST.md: such cells recorded as varying, or their values pinned
  • Seen to fail first: two runs, differing; after, the same

🤖 Filed with Claude Code -- Captain Bob, 2026-11-20: "Close #190; file POST.md".

### Found (2026-11-20, while checking #190) `make -C v4 post79` writes `docs/v4.0.0/POST.md`, the 990-case table, as well as `post_cases.c` and `POST79.md`. Those two are now the same run to run (#190), but POST.md is not. Two runs on the same tree differ in five cells of its "v3 printed" column (`logs/20261120-post79/run1-vs-run2.diff`): - three are addresses: `FIND.user_word`, `>BODY.basic` and `>BODY.variable`, despite `setarch -R`; - two come of the run's own history: `INFER-VARIANCE@.after_run` and `INFER-EARLY-EXIT@.after_run`. The cases POST runs are not affected, since v4's side does not compare these values. But POST.md, which says the tool writes it, cannot be checked against the tool, and every run leaves it modified. ### Done when - [ ] Two runs of `make -C v4 post79` on the same tree write the same POST.md: such cells recorded as varying, or their values pinned - [ ] Seen to fail first: two runs, differing; after, the same 🤖 Filed with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code) -- Captain Bob, 2026-11-20: "Close #190; file POST.md".
rajames added this to the v4.0.0-alpha.5: SDK milestone 2026-11-20 14:52:27 +00:00
Sign in to join this conversation.